Retirement Travelers

Full-time World Travel Couple

Home » The Top 10 Best Restaurants in Martha’s Vineyard (map included)
Seaside hotel with boats in the water in Martha's Vineyard, Massachusetts

The Top 10 Best Restaurants in Martha’s Vineyard (map included)

Last Updated: September 23, 2024

Martha’s Vineyard Restaurants

Martha’s Vineyard is a small island in New England off the coast of Massachusetts and is best known for its pristine natural beauty and quaint little towns. These seaside towns provide stunning views of the Aquinnah cliffs, gorgeous beaches, and a rejuvenating atmosphere. The downtown areas are full of fabulous shopping opportunities, gingerbread cottages, and delicious restaurants and cafes. 

While the island is surrounded by the sea and has a variety of sea-swept spaces, Martha’s Vineyard offers an immense amount of dining options serving only the best of the best, with plenty of fresh and local ingredients, thanks to its geological location advantage. In addition, there are so many different options for experiencing the foodie culture. From creamy chowder and fresh seafood platters to hearty steaks and homemade desserts, here are ten of the best restaurants in Martha’s Vineyard you should try during your retirement travel.

Martha’s Vineyard Restaurants Map

HOW TO SAVE THIS MAP:

Each icon has embedded information in the map, so click to review. To the right of the title of the map, click the ⭐️ STAR to save to your Google Map Account. To view it on your computer or phone, open Google Maps, click the three lines on the upper left, select “Saved,” select “Maps,” and this map will be listed below.

The Red Cat Kitchen 

The Red Cat Kitchen is located near the ferry port in Oak Bluffs and is one of the most exciting restaurants in Martha’s Vineyard. This art-filled cafe specializes in farm-to-table or sea-to-table and house-made cocktails from a reliable and dedicated staff of ox bartenders and servers. It’s not unheard of to see a celebrity or two while dining at the Red Cat Kitchen, so keep your eyes peeled. While the menu changes regularly depending on what ingredients are fresh and in season, do your best to catch the risotto and oyster pan fry for an unforgettable meal in Marthas Vineyard. 

View RESTAURANT Website

Kennebec Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 

Martha’s Vineyard Chowder Company 

Martha’s Vineyard Chowder Company sits in Oaks Bluffs in Martha’s Vineyard and specializes in house-made chowder. While typical New York style and New England style chowders are to be expected, the Chowder House offers much more, with their own take and recipes creating a creamy bowl of goodness. In addition, their chowders are always gluten-free and award-winning!

View Restaurant WEbsite

Address:
9 Oak Bluffs Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA

The Barn Bowl & Bistro 

If you are looking for a night of great food and fun entertainment, head to The Barn Bowl & Bistro. This unique and local pizza joint features some of the best pies on the island, along with Jamaican-inspired cuisine options like jerk chicken and grilled cauliflower bites. Friends and family can gather for beer and pizza night while enjoying the 10-lane bowling alley and outdoor seating areas, indulging in creative pizza with toppings of all kinds. 

View RESTAURANT Website

Address:
13 Uncas Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 

Larsen’s Fish Market 

Larsens Fish Market has provided fresh fish and seafood catches to residents and visors since 1969. Located in the fishing village of Menemsha on Marthas Vineyard, the market is open daily for lunch and dinner during spring and summer. Larsens Fish Market is said to have some of New England’s best lobster rolls and clam chowder. So grab a bite and sit at an outdoor picnic patio dining table, or grab it to go and have a picnic on the next-door beach. 

View Restaurant WEbsite

Address:
56 Basin Rd, Chilmark, MA

The Sweet Life Cafe 

The Sweet Life Cafe is a big promoter of farmers’ and fisheries’ relationships with local restaurants and serves only the freshest and best ingredients sourced locally. Sitting in a classic Cape-style home, it provides an intimate and relaxing setting with indoor and garden patio seating. While the menu changes depending on the catch, certain house favorites always make the list. For a peaceful meal in a relaxing oasis in Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts, head to the Sweet Life Cafe and indulge in delicious plates such as Squid Ink Tagliatelle or Winter Risotto.

View RESTAURANT Website

Address:
63 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 

Chef Deon’s Kitchen  

Sitting in the local VFW hall in Oaks Bluff is Chef Deon’s Kitchen. Owners Deon and Emily specialize in traditional Jamaican-style cuisine and Caribbean delicacies. New England is well known for its seafood, but Chef Deons gives it a twist of flavor from the islands down south. While the menu is ever-changing, the Spicy Jerk Chicken is always a big hit, as is the Blackened Salmon and Kale Soup for those vegetarian diners. 

View Restaurant WEbsite

Address:
Townanticut St, Oak Bluffs, MA

Square-Rigger Restaurant 

Square-Rigger Restaurant is nestled in the quaint area of Edgartown on Martha’s Vineyard and is one of the top seafood establishments in town. It is one of our favorites places to eat and it specializes in the freshest seafood catches and highest quality meats, showcasing classic New England classics and newly improved recipes. They have long been known for their clam chowder and fried fish, while other menu choices include grilled lobster, prime rib, New York strip, and an extensive wine list with a perfect match for each meal. 

View Restaurant WEbsite

Vineyard Haven Rd, Edgartown, MA 

Outermost Inn  

After a scenic drive across the island, you will likely end at the Outermost Inn. This hotel restaurant has been serving guests since 1989. It is a casual family home and has blossomed into one of the best restaurants in Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts. It is nestled on a hillside, featuring oceanside and rocky views and spectacular evening sunset opportunities. The Outermost Inn offers a rejuvenating and relaxing fine dining experience, with menu options such as jumbo asparagus, crisped duck breast, and braised lamb. 

View Restaurant WEbsite

81 Lighthouse Rd, Aquinnah, MA 

L’etoile Restaurant  

L’etoile Restaurant is a French-inspired dining establishment in the quiet neighborhood of Edgartown. The restaurant uses mainly locally sourced ingredients and produces. It creates beloved french and American classics with a New England style twist. The atmosphere is casual yet classy and elegant, with an ambiance great for date nights, intimate meals, or first impressions. Besides a full bar with an extensive cocktail list, menu favorites include lamb chops, oysters, and sweet crumbles for dessert. 

View RESTAURANT Website

22 N Water St, Edgartown, MA 

Rockfish

Rockfish is an American-style restaurant in Edgartown on Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts. It is one of the island’s best restaurants and places to eat. With a retro and trendy atmosphere, brick-walled interior, and low-lit setting, Rockfish specializes in looks and tastes. It specializes in wood-fired creations and specialty Martinis. 

View RESTAURANT Website

11 N Water St, Edgartown, MA 

Posts from New England Region

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *